Then there are the (apparent) rules. There are many new ones, many of which are driven by the vastness of the internet and the many, many voices. Some of those voices are harsh, critical, and exclusionary though, and that is a shame. In some ways I suppose it's a good thing to have some homogenization of information, but in other ways it tamps down the creativity and freedom with which we approach the plant world. However, when there weren't a million herbalists, there wasn't so much jostling to reach the top rung of the imaginary ladder. That is creating a much less welcoming environment for those just starting to look around. I'm not sure we would have been able to navigate all of this back when we first started. We might have given up.
There are hundreds of different levels of herbalism, and all of us approach it on our own terms. It seems that there is a lot of effort going on with people trying to pin down, label, and define a thing which is limitless and requires no boundaries. I'm particularly bothered by some of the rules and absolutes that people throw around. They are all well and good if one is living a pure and wholesome lifestyle, but seriously that is a very judgmental, myopic, and exclusive standpoint. We get bound and entwined by surrounding ourselves with people most like us, and forget that there's a reason there's a whole aisle filled with various brands of white bread at the grocery store. The oh-so-pure herbalist can chastise and look down on the rest of humanity all they like, but that sort of defeats the purpose in my opinion.
You want to find some herbs that will help with a chronic illness? Fine, you should not be shamed for using herbs like a pill. I believe that almost all of us first come to medicinal herbs that way. To hear some people talk about it, you'd think it was some kind of crime, but I'd be willing to bet they started that way too. Allopathy has been our mindset for 50 years and if it takes a little time to learn about prevention, constitution, energetics and all the latest jingo - it's fine. Hop onboard.
You use sugar in your syrups because maple syrup and honey are too expensive? (insert any number of individual personal preferences that can be levied for or against one's practices here) Great! Just get started. Maybe in time you'll decide that you want to switch, maybe you won't. We're glad to see you working with herbs in a way that is manageable for you. Don't let other people make you feel like you're not doing it right because you're not doing it their way.
You don't get enough exercise or eat right, but you still want to learn more about herbs? TERRIFIC! Nobody has the right to judge your lifestyle unless they're walking in the same shoes - and even then we are all individuals with different wiring. Maybe you're working too many hours and do what you can. Maybe you're caring for someone who saps all of your energy. Maybe you grew up in a family that considered fried chicken and fish to be health foods and vegetables were garnishes. Who cares? Come on in.
You can work with herbs in a tiny city apartment or a many-acred farm. You can use dried herbs you purchased, or herbs you grew from seed in soil you amended with home made compost. You can call it a dandelion or a Taraxacum officinale.
There are good reasons for most of the admonishments, so I'm not dissing them out of hand. We should use Latin names for plants so that they aren't confused. We should be learning all we can about how our bodies work and what we can do to strengthen them to prevent illness. At the same time, we must appreciate that there are a million reasons why people come to herbs, and they're not all coming from the same place. Those who have come before must be welcoming and inclusive, allowing each person to find their own comfort. Nobody owns herbalism. It belongs to everyone, and each approach is valid.
FINALLY... There are some real do's and don't's with herbs. Just because they are natural, doesn't mean they are harmless. Read books. Experiment. Learn from your mistakes. Start small, one herb at a time. Be comfortable.